Phone Chatlines vs Dating Sites [Head to Head]

Two Men: Phone vs Online Dating

Some look for long term companionship while others look for short term fun. Whatever be the reason, with the increase in the number of adults considering dating options, the ways and means of facilitating it are also increasing. Dating sites have been in the market for a while now but the option of phone chatlines are keeping users excited. The increasing options are now posing the question, “Phone Chatlines vs Dating Sites, Which is better?”

Dating sites let users create their profile, mention their interests and upload their pictures. They let you browse through the profiles of other members and even make recommendations based on the criteria entered by you. Taking up a paid membership of online dating site lets you contact individuals whose profiles you have liked. And if all goes well, you could be in for a romantic relationship.

Phone chatlines on the other hand let the users record their introductory messages. The users can listen to introductory messages of other members and if they like any voice or message, they can contact the person for a live conversation. Some chatlines also offer the option of leaving an offline message for the person. And again, things can stay over phone or progress to in-person dates depending on one’s interest.

To understand which of the two options is better, we have compared both over some parameters that are essential to every dating media and identified the winner of the two options.


Effectiveness depends on what you are looking for. If your are looking for a serious commitment and potentially the love of your life, then online dating serves the purpose better. On the other hand, if you are looking for short hook up or some steamy a phone chat to spice up mood, then phone chat lines work better. And ultimately, success in dating depends more on an individual than the medium.

Winner: It’s a Tie!


Users of online dating websites can take time to respond to messages. So if you are looking for quick response to you messages and interest, then phone chatlines are for you. You can easily speak to the person over phone — in real time — without having to wait.

Winner: Chat Lines

Ease Of Use

Online dating websites are easier to use because their layout is very similar to most social networking websites. Users can browse through profiles and view photographs. Phone chatlines require the user to listen to each introductory message which can be tedious. Also online dating websites give ample space for users to tell about themselves. But phone chatlines only give only a limited intro message.

Winner: Chat Lines


Phone chatlines are more engaging than online dating because online dating is static. You can only review profiles and pictures. Phone chat lines on the other hand is interactive and is more engaging. Depending how the conversation goes, they can even be fun. There is so much more engagement when using dating phone lines. You assess the personality of the person through their voice, the things they say, their reactions etc.

Winner: Chat Lines

Finding a match

Different dating sites use different algorithms to make recommendations and find you a match. But the level of details that the algorithms use to find a match is very different between online dating websites and phone dating chatlines. Dating sites ask their user to fill out a long form their preferences and use most of them, such as, geography, interests, personality, height, weight, language etc. to find a match. Phone dating chatlines however only use the location and genre to match users.

Winner: Dating Sites


Dating sites are much safer since the user can choose to share only limited information about themselves. They also give user to decide who they wish to continue discussions with. The pictures on profiles also ensure that the profiles are genuine.

Winner: Dating Sites


Phone chatlines are cheaper and some are even free for women. They also offer genuine free trials which make them more cost effective. This attracts many users who look for casual hookups.

Winner: Chat Lines

It cannot be concluded that any one of the dating medium is better than the other. For those who are too shy to speak up, online dating works best. For the quick and fast moving ones, phone chatlines work better. The better of the two depends entirely on who you are and what you are looking for.